Skip to main content

Apple fails to end lawsuit claiming it 'broke' FaceTime

A woman looks at the screen of her mobile phone in front of an Apple logo outside its store in Shanghai © REUTERS/Aly Song A woman looks at the screen of her mobile phone in front of an Apple logo outside its store in Shanghai Apple Inc (AAPL.O) has failed in its bid to dismiss a lawsuit claiming it disabled the popular FaceTime video conferencing feature on older iPhones to force users to upgrade.

U.S. District Judge Lucy Koh ruled late on Friday that iPhone 4 and 4S users can pursue nationwide class action claims that Apple intentionally "broke" FaceTime to save money from routing calls through servers owned by Akamai Technologies Inc (AKAM.O).

Neither Apple nor lawyers for the plaintiffs immediately responded on Monday to requests for comment.

Apple began using Akamai's servers after losing a lawsuit in 2012 in which VirnetX Holding Corp (VHC.A) claimed that FaceTime technology infringed its patents.

Testimony from a 2016 retrial in that case showed that Apple paid Akamai $50 million in one six-month period.

The plaintiffs said Apple eventually created a cheaper alternative for its iOS 7 operating system, and in April 2014 disabled FaceTime on iOS 6 and earlier systems.

Koh said the plaintiffs alleged some measurable loss to their phones' value, and could try to show that Cupertino, California-based Apple's conduct constituted a trespass and violated state consumer protection laws.

The San Jose, California-based judge twice quoted from what the plaintiffs said was an Apple employee's internal email characterizing iOS 6 users as "basically screwed" because of the disabling of FaceTime.

She also rejected Apple's argument that the plaintiffs suffered no economic loss because FaceTime was a "free" service.

"FaceTime is a 'feature' of the iPhone and thus a component of the iPhone's cost," Koh said in a footnote. "Indeed, Apple advertised FaceTime as 'one more thing that makes an iPhone an iPhone.'"

The plaintiffs are led by Christina Grace of Marin County, California, and Ken Potter of San Diego County, California, who both owned the iPhone 4. Akamai was not named as a defendant.

The case is Grace et al v Apple Inc, U.S. District Court, Northern District of California, No. 17-00551.

(Reporting by Jonathan Stempel in New York; Editing by Howard Goller)

Labels:

Popular posts from this blog

Tech 2017: Biggest fails, scandals and embarrassments

© Provided by IBT US This year brought many tech innovations and products, like the iPhone X, virtual reality headsets and augmented reality on apps. However, the tech industry also saw failures this year. Like all businesses, not all products or ideas succeed. The tech industry saw some of its gadgets fail to take off. Besides product failures, the sector was also plagued by scandals and congressional testimonies. Here are the tech industry’s 2017’s top product flops and scandals: Amazon Key In late October, Amazon announced a new delivery method for Prime members which allows drivers to set packages inside customers’ home . The delivery system works with the Amazon Key In-Home Kit that is set up for $249.99. With the kit, users can select the “in home” option on the app and get their items delivered inside their homes. Prime members can receive alerts and can see the delivery happen in real-time through the app. While the service was pitched to people who are too busy to s...
Read more

R. Tiglao Exposed LTO Records Showing Aquino Never Bought or Sold a Porsche

Veteran columnist Rigoberto Tiglao exposed the Land Transportation Office (LTO) records of former President Benigno Aquino III showing that he never bought or sold an expensive Porsche car. The LTO records proved that the former President did not sold his Porsche 911 Carrera car which he claimed he bought for P5 million. The controversial Porsche car of the former President made headlines just months into his presidency but he explained that he bought the luxury car with the proceeds he got when he sold his BMW. Because of the furor from such display of opulence, Pres. Aquino claimed to have sold it six months later for exactly the same price. According to Tiglao during that time he asked through his column the LTO to release the car's deed of sale and registration to prove that it was not a gift from a Chinese-Filipino tycoon as rumored by some individuals critical to the President. The only possible way to discover whether the Porsche luxury was indeed sold was through ...
Read more

Aktor, iniwan ang ina

PAREHAS may pinagdaanan sina Jericho Rosales at Erich Gonzales noong gawin nila ang “Siargao,” entry sa MMFF. Namatay ang daddy ni Jericho na hanggang ngayon ay hindi niya matanggap na wala na ito. Miss na miss na niya ang kanyang daddy. Nag-break naman sina Erich at Daniel Matsunaga. In a way, nakatulong kina Jericho at Erich ang pagiging abala nila sa shoot ng “Siargao” and somehow, naibsan ang kanilang kalungkutan. A month or so nanatili sila sa Siargao at gandang-ganda sila sa mga lugar na pinag-syutingan nila. Stress-free raw. Hindi na-link sa isa’t-isa sina Jericho at Erich. Taken na kasi si Jericho at happily married kay Kim Jones. Unexpectedly, kay direk Paul Soriano na happily married kay Toni Gonzaga natsismis si Erich. Walang naniwala sa ka-cheapang isyu. Nagamit pa si Toni na kuno’y pinagselosan si Erich. Balitang may non-showbiz guy na nagpapasaya ngayon ng puso ni Erich. Ang ex-boyfriend niyang si Daniel Matsunaga ay isang model mula sa Poland ang love of his life ...
Read more